‘Anti-zionism’ and ‘anti-semitism'

In local conversations, I have been particularly concerned about the meanings of ‘anti-zionism’ and ‘anti-semitism.’  Are they one and the same?  Are there distinctions between them? A child in the 1940’s, I was raised in a New York Jewish family under the horrific shadow and unimaginable abuses of ‘anti-semitism.’  Today, a woman in my 70’s, I am again being confronted with abuses of ‘anti-semitism’ and labels by people who equate criticism of Israel and of US policies towards Israel as both ‘anti-zionist’ and ‘anti-semitic.’  

I wonder if there is a discussion group concerned with this topic or if there are people who would like to form one.  I definitely need to.  To begin a conversation regarding this possibility, I see that Lillian Rosengarten, a Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany, whose recently published book Survival and Conscience: From the Shadows of Nazi Germany to the Jewish Boat to Gaza (Just World Books), will be speaking at The Inquiring Minds in Saugerties, Saturday night March 12 at 7 pm.  

Born in Nazi Germany, Lillian Rosengarten went there to talk about her book and  was featured in the Jerusalem Post at the time.  I hope that amongst the audience at the Inquiring Minds, there will be people who want to inquire more deeply into this topic. 

Jane Tob

Thank you. We applaud your accomplishments

Students for Justice in Palestine
Box 147
Vassar College
124 Raymond Avenue
Poughkeepsie, NY 12604

Dear SJP members,
We enjoyed having the opportunity to meet with you and to learn of your commendable efforts on campus and in the broader community to bring the light of knowledge to the struggle for peace with justice for Palestinians and Israelis.

From hosting the Economic Activism exhibition created by the American Friends Service Committee, to inviting distinguished professors and authors to share their perspectives, to Hip Hop music and Dabke dances, you’ve educated, entertained and opened spaces for the learning experiences that help us all grow.

Thank you.  We applaud your accomplishments and look forward to the benefits that accrue to us all through your creative work for Human Rights.  Kudos also to Vassar’s administration for its steadfast commitment to free speech and for fostering open discourse...values so vital in today’s world.

Sincerely,



Paul and Katja Rehm

Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions at Vassar Collegw

Students for Justice in Palestine 
Vassar College - Box 747
124 Raymond Ave.
Poughkeepsie, NY 12604

To the Vassar College Administration,

I want to commend two campus groups that have been particularly effective in bridging the college/community divide, Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace.

Members of both Vassar groups attended a meeting of our organization, the Middle East Crisis Response in Woodstock. Moreover, they have helped MECR educate the larger community about human rights in the Middle East. 

The more MECR works with these students, the more we are impressed by their organizational skills as well as their dedication. Advocating for Palestinian rights has not always been easy on many campuses, but these students have persevered. Their campaign this spring to bring attention to boycott, divestment and sanctions is one of the best I have seen. 

Vassar College's dedication to the free expression of ideas has most certainly enriched our wider community, and for that I sincerely thank you.

Sincerely,


Fred Nagel

Academic Engagement Network, a rightwing Zionist organization

President Hill,

A am a retired Vassar College administrator (Career Services) and I attended Dr. Puar's recent presentation.

I did not hear the inflammatory things that the Wall Street Journal claims. She did refer to the purposeful restrictions on food imports to Gaza (well substantiated by numerous reports). She also referred to the controversy surrounding organs taken from Palestinians without consent, a charge that also has a great deal of documentation <http://www.counterpunch.org/2009/08/28/israeli-organ-harvesting/>

I didn't hear any demand not be be recorded. She did say that "academic courtesy" includes being asked for permission to record a talk. Not the same thing, of course.

The authors of the Wall Street Journal article work for the Academic Engagement Network, a rightwing Zionist organization that hires retired academics to shut down campus debate on Palestinian rights.

This from a December Haaretz article: "NEW YORK – Enlisting faculty members at American colleges and universities as allies in the fraught battle against the BDS (boycotts, divestment and sanctions) movement is the main objective of a new organization [Academic Engagement Network] that is being launched on Wednesday."

The Academic Engagement Network has received tens of millions from from Sheldon Adelson, billionaire ally of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

I don't think Vassar can afford to be intimidated by extremist groups like this. As a career counselor at Vassar, many of the employers I dealt with commented on Vassar's reputation for bright and motivated student who were able to apply critical thought to solving problems. I think that shutting down critical analysis of the Israel/Palestinian conflict on campus would eventually hurt Vassar's reputation with employers.

But Vassar does not exist merely to get its graduates good jobs. Curtailing this debate on campus would also be intellectually indefensible.

Fred Nagel

Recent charges of anti-semitism leveled at Professor Jasbir Puar

Dear President Hill,

I am writing to you regarding the recent charges of anti-semitism leveled at Professor Jasbir Puar who was brought to Vassar by the Jewish Studies Department and supported by Vassar Jewish Voice for Peace.

As you probably know,  there is a well financed  campaign of intimidation  that has permeated college campuses across the nation. It is committed to  silencing all voices which are critical of Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank and Israel’s violations of Palestinian human rights. It is  also designed to stop  the burgeoning  boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement (BDS)  which is attempting to  non-violently change the policies of the Israeli government. There is a conscious, calculated,  and concerted  effort by Zionist factions to equate criticism of Israel’s government  with criticism of Jews.  This is simply not the case. In my own personal experience a large percentage of people who are critical of Israel and supportive of Palestinian human rights are, in fact, Jewish (and I include myself as a Jew who is critical of Israel).

Mr. Fred Nagel, a former Vassar administrator,  attended Dr. Puar’s talk and heard nothing anti-semitic in her remarks. I have had the privilege of knowing and working with Mr. Nagel  for many years. I have found his ability for dispassionate observation to be  extraordinary. Mr.  Nagel is a longtime local activist who is reliable, reasonable, and rational. His judgement  and integrity have always been beyond reproach.  

I am hopeful that Vassar will not succumb to these efforts to silence  voices which are critical of Israeli  governmental policies.  Certainly,  the university is a place where academic freedom and  open discourse should be encouraged and not restricted because of pressure, threats, and intimidation by right wing interest groups.   

Thank you for taking my thoughts into consideration.

Yours,

Eli Kassirer

New Paltz,  NY

ENVIRONMENT, PEACE, WARS AND MILITARISM, WEAPONS


Above photo: Destruction of Gaza from Wikimedia.
Not long ago I was standing in a veritable war zone amid the tear gas, rubber coated bullets and stun grenades looking at the little yellow flowers I was unfamiliar with and thinking about how the western main stream media portrays this particular conflict in the usual fairly unbalanced thought-bytes and the only lives that are ever considered are the human ones: some humans matter more than others but the rest of flora and fauna has, essentially, no representation in the media and apparently doesn’t matter at all.
We all know how important the environment is – ever since the word came to be in use – and, as a culture of refugees, colonialists, conquistadors and anything but the indigenous, we are indoctrinated in a culture of denial and disconnect from nature (the environment outside of your skin) and our minds and the language we think with does not contain the right sequences of words to express or question not only human rights and equality in the eyes of international law and human rights law (if that’s your thing), in the eyes of god (if that’s your thing), through a lens of your indigenous roots on Earth (regardless of where you’re from and all of the defining characteristics of your identity), but we never consider the impact of human conflict on the environment.
Trying to unravel the entangling alliances between state parties is as angrifying as actually understanding the often dubious relationships, based on economic and military power, which wreak havoc on innocent people the world over. I’m specifically avoiding examples because there are so many to choose from I don’t want to single out one perpetrator over another and draw a chorus of “what about the others’ “. Besides that’s not my point.
My point is that all of that is somewhat irrelevant – the behavior is basically universal in that people are making, selling, buying, and using weapons to kill innocent people and it’s generally not sanctioned by the respective civil societies of the nation-states doing the killing. The underlying issue, which gains absolutely no attention in the press, in social media, from political pundits and the politicians themselves, is the simple set of questions everyone should be asking themselves with their morning coffee, afternoon cocktail, dinner and a joint, is “Who’s making all of these weapons? Who’s selling all of these weapons? Who’s using all of these weapons? And why are they being made, sold, bought, used and not regulated in any consistent fashion, let alone produced at all – when they have only one purpose?”
I’m not gonna answer that simple set of questions. I have my own thoughts and beliefs about why this is taking place. The once in a while that I can bear to think about it I just ask myself “why isn’t everyone talking about this and trying to do something about the way these forms of commerce take place?”
Generally, energy flows where attention goes so let us all put some form of attention to this issue. It can be in the form of prayer, mediation, poetry, music, dance, food, letters and phone calls and general lobbying of government officials and weapons manufacturers, letters to editors, peace journalists can participate in focusing their attention on this matter as well. Of course, there are more than one hundred and ninety-eight methods of non-violent armed resistance according to one Gene Sharp (If you’re reading this you know how to use a search engine). I can’t do all 198, but I try a few here and there in a way that doesn’t interfere too much with my white male American middle aged middle classed privilege. I’m asking you do something too. Few are guilty, all are responsible.
 -Adam Roufberg is a scientist and educator and has recently completed and MAS in Peace Studies and Conflict Transformation focusing on how the arts can be used as a playground for establishing relationships based on common characteristics of our human identities and constructing a new narrative based on a hunger for learning about our differences in a way that promotes mutual understanding, appreciation and enjoyment.

Dear Kevin Cahill Assemblyman

Dear Kevin Cahill Assemblyman

I am writing to you in favor of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution (freedom of speech), and freedom of religion.
I am Jewish. However I have never chosen the State of Israel to represent me as a Jew. I don't agree with its Zionist and anti- Palestinian policies. Israel has disobeyed several United Nations rulings regarding the West Bank and has broken Geneva Accords
that the U.S. is signatory to regarding the occupation of land conquered in war. I am first an American Citizen before anything.

The U.S constitution guarantees me the right of free assembly and public expression of my views. In S 6378A/A9036 the government would take away my right as an American citizen to criticize the misbehavior of a foreign power(_Israel_) And to organize against their lawlessness in the form of BDS or any other way I would like to organize within my constitutional  rights.I am a Jew. I don't hate myself for being a Jew. But I hold in bad respect the behavior of the State of Israel. It Doesn't represent all Jews and has no right to.
Therefore I ask you to vote against and organize against A9036.  
       
 Gregor Sirotof